Medicaid & Medicare drive up insurance premiums

A common, and flawed, justification for mandatory medical insurance is that the uninsured drive up the costs of insurance premiums.  You know, by using the emergency room for their medical care.  Yet, as I’ve noted before, Medicaid patients burden ERs more than the uninsured.   Worse yet, Medicaid and Medicare increase insurance premiums.  From Bloomberg.com:

Employers and private health insurers pay a “hidden tax” of $88.8 billion each year because government programs fail to pay enough to doctors and hospitals, an industry-sponsored study found.

Inadequate reimbursements by programs such as Medicare and Medicaid increase the annual cost of covering a family of four by $1,788, according to the report, issued today by the actuarial consulting firm Milliman Inc. At hospitals, the payment gap between private and public insurance has more than doubled in 10 years, the Seattle-based firm said.

This is yet more reason to replace Medicaid and Medicare with tax credits or vouchers for private insurance, as discussed here.

The Milliman study is here: Hospital and physician cost shift, by Will Fox and John Pickering.

(via John Goodman)

Similar Posts:

This entry was posted in mandatory insurance, myths & fallacies and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.
  • http://www.patientpowernow.org/2009/04/12/colorado-hb-1293-expensive-medical-insurance/ Colorado HB 1293: Prepare For More Expensive Medical Insurance | Independence Institute: Patient Power

    [...] “uninsured cost-shift scam.” Compare this to Medicare and Medicaid: Bloomberg recently reported that “Medicare and Medicaid increase the annual cost of covering a family of four by [...]

  • http://www.patientpowernow.org/2009/07/11/public-option-private-option-health-care/ Instead of a “public option,” how about a “private option”? | Independence Institute: Patient Power

    [...] included (Denver Post, July 5).  Yet she neglects to mention the problems. For example, how they increase private insurance premiums by underpaying doctors, how doctors often refuse to see patients, and how these financially [...]

  • http://www.patientpowernow.org/2009/07/13/colorado-medicaid-reimbursement-rates/ CO Medicaid cuts reimbursement rates. Will your insurance premiums go up? | Independence Institute: Patient Power

    [...] For more on that, see here. [...]

  • http://73wire.com/2009/11/u-s-health-care-reform-states-hit-hardest/ U.S. Health-Care Reform: States Hit Hardest | 73 Wire

    [...] cost-shifting to those with commercial insurance: “when Medicare does try to cut costs, it usually does so by cutting reimbursements to doctors. This results in cost-shifting from the government onto the backs of private insurers, employers, patients, and most of all, doctors. The most recent data available show that Medicare alone shifted $48.9 billion in costs onto the backs of the private sector one year.”  Read more on the cost-shift from Medicare and Medicaid. [...]